Blue Jays Recall Four Players, Lose Joe Mantiply to Free Agency
By Tara West · Sharper Points AI Desk · Edited by Jordan HawkesPublished On September 28, 2026, the Toronto Blue Jays processed five roster transactions, recalling four players to the major league roster and seeing one pitcher depart via free agency. LHP Ricky Tiedemann, LF Yohendrick Pinango, and C Shawn Ross were recalled from the Buffalo Bisons, alongside RHP CJ Van Eyk from the FCL Blue Jays, while LHP Joe Mantiply elected free agency. These additions and subtractions adjust Toronto's active depth following a 10-game stretch that yielded a 4-6 record.
Verified Roster Transactions
The following roster changes were officially recorded by the team on September 28, 2026:
| Player | Transaction Kind | Source / Detail |
|---|---|---|
| Ricky Tiedemann | Recall | Recalled from Buffalo Bisons |
| Yohendrick Pinango | Recall | Recalled from Buffalo Bisons |
| CJ Van Eyk | Recall | Recalled from FCL Blue Jays |
| Shawn Ross | Recall | Recalled from Buffalo Bisons |
| Joe Mantiply | Other | Elected free agency |
As reported facts, four players join the active roster while Joe Mantiply departs after electing free agency. Three recalls—Ricky Tiedemann, Yohendrick Pinango, and Shawn Ross—come directly from Triple-A Buffalo, while CJ Van Eyk was recalled from the FCL Blue Jays.
Pitching Roster Shifts and Recent Performance
Evaluating the pitching staff requires looking at Toronto's recent team form. Between September 16 and September 27, the Blue Jays pitching staff held opponents to an average of 3.9 runs per game over a 10-game sample, compiling a 3.35 ERA.
Analysis of these figures indicates that pitching was not the central cause of Toronto's 4-6 record over this span. The departure of Joe Mantiply to free agency subtracts a left-handed pitching option, while the recalls of left-hander Ricky Tiedemann and right-hander CJ Van Eyk introduce two fresh arms. Based strictly on team-level statistics, bringing in Ricky Tiedemann and CJ Van Eyk alters roster availability, but the existing pitching staff had already performed to a 3.35 ERA baseline prior to these moves.
Positional Depth and Run Production Baseline
In addition to the pitching adjustments, Toronto recalled outfielder Yohendrick Pinango and catcher Shawn Ross from Buffalo. Looking at the team's recent offensive metrics places these position player additions into context.
Over the 10-game sample from September 16 through September 27, Toronto's offense generated an average of 3.4 runs and 7.3 hits per game, alongside 1.3 home runs per game. Analysis shows a clear run differential deficit: despite allowing only 3.9 runs per game, the team produced just 3.4 runs per game. Recalling Yohendrick Pinango and Shawn Ross adds two position players to the major league roster, but whether their arrival impacts overall team output remains to be seen against the established 3.4 runs-per-game standard. Without individual minor league metrics or upcoming game data provided, the verified facts simply confirm that Toronto refreshed its active roster across both pitching and position player spots on September 28.
Sources
More from the Sharp Report: all MLB articles · Toronto Blue Jays